Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | jjx's commentslogin

jjx here. This is not propaganda, nor is it incendiary. It's the truth. I have been promoting App Engine to everyone I talk to, because of the ease of deployment and the promise of scalability. I have been waiting for months for the beta quotas to be lifted. My wait has been in vain. It seems that scalability to Google means it will scale on one little machine in their infrastructure. If 500 requests per second is the best I can get from "10 years of knowledge Google has in running massively scalable, performance driven systems", then the hype of Google is a fiction.


All you have to do is ask them to raise your quota.

Why are you omitting this fact?

http://code.google.com/support/bin/request.py?contact_type=A...


jjx here (The original poster). My blog post is accurate. Read the description of scalability that Google provides. It implies that you can scale to any degree. 500 request a second is an absolute joke. I can use any web development environment (like Rails), and get 500 requests per second on a crappy little machine. So App Engine doesn't scale, at all.

The main reason I wrote this post is out of utter frustration with Google. They should get out of the developer tools business. For months I have been coding around their onerous and ridiculous quotas, waiting for the nirvana of paid quotas, only to be horrified by the new quotas. If these quotas are not lifted, then I've completely wasted my time. As it stands now, I'm abandoning App Engine.


"if these quotas are not lifted"

Did you ask them to increase your quota?

http://code.google.com/support/bin/request.py?contact_type=A...


On your blog, you put this in comments:

"For all those saying that "all I need to do is ask (beg) Google for more quota, read this:"

http://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/81f1k/the_googl...

I read that and it seems like the person is talking about not getting a special free quota he had and that he was in negotiations for (but had not heard back yet)?

That seems like a completely different situation to me than a paying customer who wants to increase their quota.

Note that this translates to "give Google more money" so I don't know why you think this is something like begging.

On Amazon, they also want to make money and they happily increase quotas. They just want to know what's up, if you're a legitimate customer who's really going to pay them and not do a chargeback on the credit card the first month, etc.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: