Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Proton: Multitouch Gestures as Regular Expressions [pdf] (pixar.com)
29 points by mjswensen on Aug 5, 2015 | hide | past | favorite | 8 comments


How long before gestures move off the screen surface? This technology got off to an exciting start but it quickly hit a wall. It was disappointing, for example, when Microsoft had to unbundle the Kinect.

Microsoft's Kinect - 2010

Leap Motion - 2010

Intel Real Sense - http://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/architecture-and-tech...

Google's Soli chip - 2016 - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0QNiZfSsPc0

Google's Touch Sensitive Fabric: http://www.wired.com/2015/05/google-atap-project-soli-gestur...


I've done a lot of full 3D gestures work. They work well, but people are finding it hard to come up with workable interactions to care about/spend battery on.

Google's new stuff had an opportunity to move gestures off the screen, mostly because it is low power/localized rather than high power/installations/invasive.


The Kinect as-is really had no future. It was too limited for gaming and too clunky for anything else. I do think the tech is great - if not amazing, but only if its part of a larger pie. MS's Hololens with a Kinect reading your body/hands/face/fingers makes a lot of sense to me. AR that's aware of your every move can be big, perhaps even a game changer in some/many industries.

At my desktop, I really don't need anything like Kinect. I can type on a keyboard or use a mouse. Or swipe on the nearby screen. Gesturing is clunky in those scenarios. Now put an AR headset on my face and set me loose. Now I need some kind of remote input that I don't carry around. That's something AR needs and MS has a major lead here.


When the basic essential interactions like "select" feel natural and unambiguous -- holding your hand in place for Kinect wasn't a good replacement for "click"/"tap".


The future is fingerguns. "Pew pew to open program".


Here it is as a Github project: https://github.com/ucbvislab/Proton


Really really good article. These kind of easy to understand research results, but hard to think of yourselve are often the best. Respect


Damn, I wondered about that back in college, except my teachers hated grammars and regexps.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: