Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Murdering someone would prevent them from committing suicide. Being suicidal is not quite the same as wishing to be murdered.

As far as I know, suicide (or self-euthanasia) does not have a settled, common ethical ground. Some cultures abhor it, and some expect it. A few have some problems with the occasional suicide-by-murderous-rampage. Thus, any "universal" ethics would not be able to answer any questions about it in a consistent way.

Suicide is a corner case, anyway. The above 4 rules can probably handle at least 80% of ethical dilemmas without much additional thought.

Certainly, if you think you would like to know whether a government or multinational is acting against your interests, and you discover evidence of it in your employer, you should sever your relationship by rule #1, blow the whistle by rule #2, and try to remain anonymous by rule #4. Additionally, the worst retaliation you should fear is to have your own bad behavior outed to the public, by rule #3. But you already know your employer is unethical, so who knows what they might do to you?

The world would probably be a better place without rule #4, but that's describing what we are, not what we wish to be.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: