Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Again, not assault and not a thug. If frisking is assault, and anyone who does it as an employee of some organization, then by your logic all police commit assaults, and all police are thugs. Clearly, they are not. If a police officer frisks you, under normal circumstances, that is both legal and expected. It's a security measure.

A thug would be somebody who carries out a simple violent crime under orders of somebody else, who is also not legally allowed to do such activity (say, a gang leader or organized crime leader.).

A fundamental basis of government is that it is the only socially authorized entity who can commit violence and/or otherwise restrict a person's movements. We as a society give government the right to do that.



> Again, not assault and not a thug.

Again, incorrect; if a person feels assaulted because you grabbed their junk against their will, then they've been assaulted.

> If a police officer frisks you, under normal circumstances, that is both legal and expected.

Fist off, ex cop here. No, it isn't expected. Cops require cause to frisk you and generally only do it if you're suspected of something and we make an exception for police because we all agree they have to be able to do it. There is no such agreement that the TSA needs such power.

Secondly, they'll generally have a member of the same sex do the frisk because they recognize people do see being groped as being assaulted. Most people let it go because they're happy to not be in trouble, not because they like it.

> We as a society give government the right to do that.

Correct, however, the TSA is not the government. They're private thugs. And yes, many cops are thugs as well, it's why I left the profession. It's a career field full of power hungry ex jocks who think bullying people is their current sport. Most have little understanding of the law, they do whatever they're trained on the job to do with little thought of whether or not they should.


> Correct, however, the TSA is not the government.

http://www.tsa.gov/


Doh, why did I think the TSA was something the airlines were doing. Hm, I'll have to rethink it, I don't want the government doing it either because just like the cops, they're abusing it.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: