Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Correct, iexplore.exe is itself a small wrapper. But that doesn't stop Microsoft from not shipping that small wrapper. Software that embeds mshtml.dll does not require the existence of the exe file.

(Or alternatively, Microsoft could put some hack into Windows so that attempts to run iexplore.exe are passed to Edge unless the administrator has twiddled with some arbitrary registry key or group policy.)



> But that doesn't stop Microsoft from not shipping that small wrapper.

They could but that goes back to reply about it existing software still requiring IE.

IE will be around for as long as very critical apps still require it. In some form, it might be around forever.


IE should just be a compatibility mode in edge so you only have one program and a button to say "this page is broken, load in legacy mode". That way everyone else in the world can stop being forced to support IE users.


This won't work where ActiveX is required. They would have to write a plug-in wrapper...


The legacy mode would surely run MSHTML.dll for the entire page.


> But that doesn't stop Microsoft from not shipping that small wrapper.

But what's the benefit of complicating the install?


1. Most people will never install it.

2. A smaller OS.

3. A more secure OS (the wrapper probably isn't bug free).


> the wrapper probably isn't bug free

This probably only matters if it's attempted to be used.

I will concede that you will save a few MB on your multi-GB Windows install.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: