Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

If you always drive a newer car and rely on a dealer for service, you no longer control what you drive when those dealers only sell self driving cars. (Or when the service model shifts as electrics have fewer service items and the service department closes)


The myth that electric cars require less service needs to die.

Maintenance needs in any modern car mostly comes back to value engineering. It's literally someone's job to optimize "how cheaply can we make this part, that it breaks just often enough that people won't complain".

The exact same thing is already happening for electric cars, and you'll need to spend exactly the same amount of time and money on service.

Furthermore, almost none of the service on a modern car is related to the combustion engine itself. It's mainly electronics, linkages, wheel beqrings, shocks, suspension, rust damage, tires etc.

If you think about it, a car that's done 200 000 miles at EOL has only been running for around 200 days continuously. A generator, or the engine on a ship, train, airplane etc. runs more than a full order of magnitude longer.


I drive an electric (LEAF) for a little over 5 years and also maintain my wife’s characteristically low maintenance car (Honda CR-V). Despite being very low maintenance, her car is much more maintenance intensive than my car. In five years, I’ve filled the washer fluid several times, changed the wiper blades, and plugged one flat tire. On her car, oil changes alone have taken more time, to say nothing of the brakes, power steering pump, valve adjustment, exhaust gasket change, and a handful of other jobs (all small).

In my case, the “myth” very much matches my experience.


ICE cars these days typically have electric power steering. And BEVs have brakes. I don't think ICE cars necessarily need valve adjustment - doesn't Honda use solid lifters where others use hydraulics?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: