Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Very interesting. Did anyone else look at this, and think it was super complicated, at first glance? You’d have to be an expert in the data exchange format itself.

I can see why Lisp style syntax is bad for human comprehension. It’s because of the lack of an explicit delimiter, like a comma. I don’t think human eyes are very good at using a single space character, as a delimiter.

And with this format, you’d have to agree upon the data exchange structure. There would have to be a master key somewhere, maybe as the header. Albeit, this format is far more efficient than XML.

But, XML probably won out because it was explicit, and allowed multiple levels of nesting, but at the expense of overly wordy delimiter tags.

And JSON made it simpler, by forcing it to be a lightweight key-value pair.

It’s too bad something like this didn’t take root and become more popular. This might be a very useful advanced data exchange format for some scenarios. Although the headaches and problems associated with trying to understand, and work with it, might far outweigh its efficiency benefits.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: