Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I couldn't tell by your question if you were referring to the Pi cluster or asking an unrelated question about 802.11s mesh clusters... :)

Here are my answers for both:

Pi cluster: meshing won't save any additional wires here since there is already a wireless bridge set up (between the black Mikrotik device pictured, and an off-camera Mikrotik wireless router.) I chose to wire the cluster simply to guarantee a reliable connection within the cluster. You can absolutely use a Raspberry Pi over WiFi without an Ethernet cable, it would just be a less reliable connection (jitter, congestion), and then of course it would have to be powered conventionally rather than via PoE.

General 802.11s meshing: If all you want is fewer network cabling in your home specifically between switches and access points, then it could certainly help. However, the best choice network-wise is almost always a proper deployment with a central router and several APs (broadcasting the same SSID) wired back to it.



I guess I was curious about both, thanks for yours answers! I hadn't thought about PoE, having never used it myself, so indeed at one cable per device there's not much more to do.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: