Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's strange - the article talks about it being this 20-year favorite, but I didn't see it show up in US bookstores until the last few years.


I read the first edition when I was in high school eleven years ago. Even back then it was considered the standard go-to book for learning the basics of algorithms and data structures. If your bookstores weren't carrying it, they must have not have been well stocked.

My opinion of the book nowadays is actually somewhat low. The content and style is competent but generic and uninspiring. It does a poor job of teaching algorithm design, but admittedly that is a flaw with most of these books. Udi Manber's lesser-known textbook is just a lot better in that regard. It does mean sacrificing some breadth of coverage compared to CLR. For me it's the right trade-off because so much of CLR's coverage comes across as perfunctory, as if they're just checking boxes off an endless curriculum list that's intended to please everyone, much like the big calculus books. The grab bag of advanced chapters in the book's last half are the exception to that rule. They're usually in the authors' own research areas, and it shows.


Which bookstores? Most don't sell textbooks, except for university bookstores.


Every Borders and Barnes & Nobles that I lived near. They do carry a few hard-core algorithms books and eventually it did show up there.

It's true that I don't get to university bookstores as often as I'd like.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: