Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

If you look at the claims they actually patented this (I translated it into English):

> For a scanner with a near and far end, position one cart near the near end. Remove a tray from the cart. Pass it through the scanner. Put the tray in a second cart at the far end of the scanner. Move the second cart to the near end of the scanner.

I'm not exaggerating. That's what claim 1 says. If you do that they can sue you for infringement.

The subordinate claims talk about stackable trays, but you only have to infringe claim 1 to be infringing. Claim 1 is written as broadly as possible in order to "catch" as many infringers as possible, and then the subordinate claims are there in case the courts actually rule that claim 1 was too broad.

So you can say "Fine, we can't patent using a cart to move trays, but what about claim 3? We patented using stackable trays! That's very novel!"



> We patented using stackable trays!

I'd just start gesturing wildly at cafeteria trays that have been around for decades.


Yeah but did you put them on a cart? No!! N.. oh you did. Ok fine but did you put them on a cart near an X-ray machine? Ha!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: