Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> as currently perpetrated in the large by Apple, and spun even by people here as a worthwhile tradeoff for "security"

See this misses the more nuanced point. I bet my last cent that everyone who doesn't want Apple's ability to meaningfully control their platform eroded would change their tune immediately if we had a regulatory environment that had any teeth whatsoever when it comes to policing malicious software.

People are currently backed into a corner where the only not incompetent regulatory body for software is Apple right now. I would love for iOS to be completely open but maligned actors who would use that against my interests need to be stopped and Apple being closed doesn't get in the way all that much.

* You must be able to cancel subscriptions in one click with no human interaction and users must be able to choose an immediate cancel for a pro-rated refund even if they paid "yearly."

* You must allow opt-out of all tracking and data collection without providing any disincentive for doing so.

* All free trails must not require a CC and can only be continued after explicitly done so by the user.

* Delete the concept of implied consent. By existing you consent to.. fuck off.

* Establish a legal definition of dark pattern and make them illegal and reportable by users for a cut of the fine.

* You must be allowed to purchase a completely ad free experience.

* You cannot sell OS features like notifications or running in the background.

* All digital goods must be able to be returned within x days of purchase.

My wishlist could go on.



> I bet my last cent that everyone who doesn't want Apple's ability to meaningfully control their platform eroded would change their tune immediately if we had a regulatory environment that had any teeth whatsoever when it comes to policing malicious software.

I definitely would change my mind. The complete lack of any effective protections against bad actors is the sole reason I'm willing to tolerate what Apple is doing with the iOS App Store.


Those who exchange freedom for security deserve neither.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: