Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The companies don't have nearly enough assets to pay for clean up.

Would be more just to seize them and auction them off for enough funds to do 1-5% cleanup, but that would probably be an uphill battle politically.



> Would be more just to seize them and auction them off for enough funds to do 1-5% cleanup

A good portion of the companies behind superfund sites, in the US no longer exist, or are the US government.

At this point, subsidized reverse osmosis systems would probably be cheaper than cleaning up the mess.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Superfund_sites


> Would be more just to seize them and auction them off for enough funds to do 1-5% cleanup, but that would probably be an uphill battle politically.

I'm guessing that if the American public saw the government actually hold a company and its shareholders accountable for knowingly poisoning their children it'd be massively popular politically. Lobbyists would have it.


Any genuinely terrible idea should be an uphill battle politically.

Do you know how much you, personally, benefit from modern material science? Do you think our nation could even operate with out Bayer, Dupont, 3M and the likes?


We are about to find out if we can do without 3M as they face eradication from a $140B cleanup litigation https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-06-02/3m-heads-...


We could always keep the company and fry the shareholders and executives responsible. If there ever were a company the nation couldn't do without, the only sane answer is for the government to take it over for national security reasons. Otherwise that company could hold the US hostage, or be bought out/taken over by foreign interests and used to collapse the entire country while we'd be powerless to stop it.


What you are describing is "expropriation." Cuba and Venezuela both did it. So if you want the US to look more like Venezuela, keep it up


As if that was the one thing that put Venezuela in the position it is in now. Venezuela does a lot of things we already do in the US too, but somehow we aren't identical either. Maybe our situations are more complex than "this one weird trick will salvage/destroy your country"




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: