Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Why can't the TSA rent-a-thugs be cops or something? At least they'd be deterring crimes that actually happen.


Cops have generalist training that can be used across a wide variety of situations where you have to think on your feet. It would be a waste of that training to just chain it to a scanner week-in, week-out.


He meant the other way around. Train the TSA agents to be cops instead and have them do actual police duty instead of hanging around airports being annoying obstacles for travelers.


You want those imbeciles to have guns?

And what crimes happen in the vicinity of their screening area that could be prevented?


The main crime in screening areas, beyond violation of people's rights, is probably TSA employees stealing things.


> You want those imbeciles to have guns?

No, he wants real cops.

In France, in public places like railway stations, the "plan Vigipirate" makes use of the military (including gendarmerie)


No one is hiring cops. Listen to this week's This American Life; small-government fetishists are firing public workers, and for very good reasons.


The TSA _are_ deterring crimes. Drug related crimes (possession) has gone up substantially at airports, and there are known cases of credit card fraud, animal smuggling and child porn being found while searching belongings of travelers.

Whether or not you think that the TSA should be involved in anything past securing the ability for persons to travel is the question.


erm, isn't "catching people committing a crime" proof that the crimes are not being deterred?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: