Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> I, like the person you're responding to, have experienced the zeitgeist of HN

I'm sure you have. And I've experienced the opposite. There's a natural tendency to pay more attention to criticism of one's own views and to come to believe that only one's own views are persecuted, based on one's anecdotal experience, but that view isn't empirically accurate in the aggregate. Again, dang, who has observed countless these kind of complaints on HN, has written about the phenomenon many times. He could probably cite a bunch of examples.



While I hear what you're saying, it's bordering on an appeal to authority. Dang is just one person and has his own set of biases


> While I hear what you're saying, it's bordering on an appeal to authority. Dang is just one person and has his own set of biases

My point about dang is that (1) dang has seen more HN comments that literally anyone else in the world and thus has more knowledge about this topic than anyone else in the world; (2) dang specifically sees the posts and comments that have been flagged, because of his job as moderator; (3) dang has seen (and can probably cite) the comments from all ideological standpoints complaining that that the opposite viewpoint is dominant on HN and that their views have been censored.

It's an appeal to vast experience and knowledge.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: