Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> How do you scribble "family of three: mom, father, daughter" without any emojis?

How often do people need to do that; with that level of fidelity, right down to the composition of the family? My suspicion is not often. A short sentence does this description just as good and is much less ambiguous, as in written, concise communication that is "emoji-rich" is filled with so many details (such as the composition of the family and their skintone) it's often not clear which details are important for the message and which are not. In addition because emojis are rendered differently on different devices the meaning may be lost (e.g. when apple changed the gun emoji to a watergun, many messages took on different meanings depending on if a revolver was used or a watergun)



> How often do people need to do that;

Surprisingly, this happens. I recently started to use a lot of emojis, including ones like these, to name calendar events - because I use a watch face on my smartwatch that renders the next 12 hours worth of events on the clock face, and given the small space, many of the events can fit three or four letters of description. Emojis work as great workaround, because I can encode things like "takeoff, gate A11" in 4 visual characters, or "doctor's visit" in one.

(I prefix the event titles with emojis rather than replace the longer form completely, because some of those events are shared, and sometimes I forget what an emoji stands for anyway...)

Now, this is perhaps an unique use case, but I found myself doing this in other scenarios too, like task planners - the common thread is, "not enough space to fit full label".


> A short sentence does this description just as good and is much less ambiguous

so you're now dictating what can be said, rather than designing a system for which _anything_ that could be said is possible?

You're missing the goal of a system of writing and representation.


The system exists. It's text.


how would you write something that's not ascii character based, such as hieroglyphs?


A set of hieroglyphs for a formally designed and recognized language that is in use to communicate is one thing. Endless bits of arbitrary clip art is another.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: