Is it perfect at those things? Of course not. Can you and I and others provide a bunch of examples of those things not happening? Of course. It's still damned good at them.
Are you talking about specific subreddits or topics?
I’ve found the negativity on Reddit to be more likely as to come from completely ignorant sources as anyone with actual knowledge. I'm pretty surprised anyone on there for a long period of time would be so trusting of the community there.
> Are you talking about specific subreddits or topics?
I'm talking about the culture of the entire site. From tiny subreddits to huge ones and every topic.
> I’ve found the negativity on Reddit to be more likely as to come from completely ignorant sources as anyone with actual knowledge.
Maybe we're talking about different things here. You seem to be referring to jerks. I was referring to people calling stuff out. People can call things out politely. One could say you're doing it right now - you disagree with me and you're explaining why. You're not being negative but what you're doing would be an example of what I mean. Redditors do this. If they see something they think is wrong, they say so. Sometimes in great numbers. Sometimes politely, sometimes very rude. Sometimes with the IQ of a hamster and sometimes it's a genius. But they let you know.
> I'm pretty surprised anyone on there for a long period of time would be so trusting of the community there.
I don't know what you mean by trusting. They're not always right. I don't automatically believe whatever they say. It's like in Jackie Brown. 'You can't trust melanie, but you can always trust melanie to be melanie.' I trust Reddit to be Reddit. If they see something they don't agree with or think is false or think is misleading or think is not the best way - they're gonna let you know.
15+ years of living on Reddit.
Is it perfect at those things? Of course not. Can you and I and others provide a bunch of examples of those things not happening? Of course. It's still damned good at them.
I expanded at length here on how this works with regard to people trying to promote their products: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37703112
But it applies to all sorts of stuff, depending on the subreddit. Investing advice, sports trivia, historical facts, whatever.