Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Canada to require registration of podcasters and streaming services (canada.ca)
38 points by baggy_trough on Oct 1, 2023 | hide | past | favorite | 22 comments


I want to add a bit of context from the government’s article:

> Online streaming services that operate in Canada, offer broadcasting content, and earn $10 million or more in annual revenues will need to complete a registration form by November 28, 2023.


Yeah so they target all the major podcasting streaming services like Spotify. Dark path.


Yeah, wonderful. Check this out:

On one hand they require distribution services to register, read Apple or Spotify. On another they require them "to make content available in a way that is not tied to a specific mobile or Internet service." Would be nice to know what they were smoking, because that's how you kill all podcast distribution in Canada.

And all it took to produce this piece of legislation were mere 4 months of "public consultations".


The title has been editorialized in a way that is incorrect. The article states:

- Social media services must register; however, users do not.

- Online services that offer podcasts must register; however, individuals who use social media to share podcasts do not.

That to me clearly indicates that "podcasters" do not need to register.


It does kill the independent podcaster who hosts and serves their own content.

Downfall of Canada continues.


You should read the details to become informed on the topic before feigning fear and anxiety.


No it doesn’t.

They would have to earn $10 million dollars or more in annual revenue to be affected.


For now...


I haven't seen an even remotely popular decision come from the CRTC in decades. I think maybe the last thing they did that anyone actually thought was worth while was unbundling cable packages... well into the decline of cable television.

Everything else, makes them obvious enemies of basically all Canadians. Selling out to massive telecoms and setting up meaningless laws to make content production and distribution harder in Canada.

I can honestly say I have no respect for anyone working under the purview of the CRTC.


…and ensure online streaming services make meaningful contributions to Canadian and Indigenous content.

Not loving that phrasing. The only reason you’d be this opaque is because you want to hide your intentions.


No, Canada has had laws promoting Canadian Content (CanCon) for many years now. What’s new is that they’re now extending these protections to online media.


I’m not exactly a fan of CanCon laws but I’m shocked it took this long to extend to web-delivered media.


making over 10 million a year... i feel like that is fair


In a galaxy far away they dqy for wahman and tsaldran


if one believes that this agency/law/act will not lower the "$10M" in the future I have some lake front property in FL to sell you.... Agencies are ALWAYS about expanding/taking more/pushing limits

great job CN!!!!!!!


They could lower it to 100k and it probably won't affect most podcasts. Any point below that isn't really worth the extra bureaucratic hurdle anyway as the author will file taxes anyway.



Example 82,462,147 of "you get wht you vote for"


The new Act does NOT affect podcasts.


“Online services that offer podcasts must register; however, individuals who use social media to share podcasts do not.”

They only want to control the means by which podcasts are distributed.


Micro censorship. Step by step.

How does one really define a podcast anyway? Me hosting any audio file which is not music and has people talking?


As the “services that offer podcasts” can bit a bit of a racket, it’s possible that putting your podcast on your own website classifies your website as an “online service” and therefore that controls independent creators




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: