Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Morgan didn't want that wireless junk

Good for him: It's physically impossible.



An honest question: Why is wireless broadcast of electricity physically impossible?


Because the power of electromagnetic radiation (energy per unit area perpendicular to the source) drops off proportional to the inverse square of the distance. So, at one unit away it's a reference for full power, at two units it's at one-quarter power, and three units it's at one-ninth power, and so on. This is the fatal flaw with Tesla's scheme: By simple geometry, you're pouring power into space and you need massive input to get any output at all at an appreciable distance.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inverse-square_law

The WiTricity project you may hear of does things based on a completely different technical footing, which is more efficient but less broadly useful. For example, with the WiTricity technology, power receivers can't be any more than a quarter-wavelength from the transmitter, which means that they can't be any further away than a few meters. Definitely not what Tesla had in mind.


You've read enough of Tesla's diaries to know that?


> You've read enough of Tesla's diaries to know that?

I know enough physics to know that. Tesla's diaries are irrelevant.


Marin Soljačić might disagree.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marin_Soljačić


I'm sure he wouldn't: There's a reason his work is completely different from Tesla's.

And our discussion is about Tesla's broadcast power ideas. Bringing in a completely different concept is dishonest.


The discussion was about wireless transmission of power. It was stated that it was impossible. It's a reality.

I'm refraining from further conversation. Good evening.


The claim was that wireless is "junk". Soljačić proved it's not.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: