Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

But then, who'd invent excel? Maybe we need the compromise and let some people be the 10xcel engineer...


For sure, I just don't see it coming out of a place of "I need to analyze my credit card statement"

Excel wasn't built out of a small personal project, it was a huge multi engineer project built on microsoft (built upon decades of spreadsheet software tradition and arguably centuries of accounting tradition), by a company that had a huge userbase that acted as stakeholders for managing the data and accounts of multi million dollar companies and small businesses alike.

I think that complex contraptions arise more from complex necessities than overengineering a solution from a simple problem


The VisiCalc/Lotus erasure is very strong in this comment.


Wouldn't they fit within the "decades of spreadsheet software tradition"?


> Excel wasn't built out of a small personal project,

But another program with a similar impact -- dBase, the precursor to Microsoft Access, was. Cecil Ratliff wrote it to manage football statistics so he could win his office football pool.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: