that's an understatement. it just looks like RGB noise effect was added. film grain does not look like RGB noise. to me, film grain is only one part of what gave film the film look. the way the highlights bloom rather than clip. it also was more natural/organic/some descriptive other than the ultrasharp of modern digital acquisition. using some SoftFX or Black Mist type filters help, but it's just not the same as it is a digital vs analog type of acquisition. all of these attempts at making something look like it's not just keep falling down in the same ways. but hey, there's a cool tech blog about it this time. film grain filters have been around for a long time, yet people just don't care for them. even in Blu-ray time frame, there was attempts at removing the grain in the encode and applying it in playback. Netflix isn't coming up with anything new, and apparently nothing exciting either based on the results.
Agree, I really prefer luminance noise when simulating film grain rather than treating RGB so independently - the RGB here looks wrong to me. If you are thinking about film, you wouldn't model it as pure photon/detector noise, because film has some crystalline structure and usually there is some correlation between the channels. (Some of the best grain is on B&W films though, which have wonderful structure and statistics.)
I only have their single sample in the blog post to go by, but the original source frame also looks just like RGB noise? And the recreation looks really close if I swap between them. Looks fine to me.
So as long they're analyzing the style of grain in the source properly, which the technical part of the post mentions they do...
that's an understatement. it just looks like RGB noise effect was added. film grain does not look like RGB noise. to me, film grain is only one part of what gave film the film look. the way the highlights bloom rather than clip. it also was more natural/organic/some descriptive other than the ultrasharp of modern digital acquisition. using some SoftFX or Black Mist type filters help, but it's just not the same as it is a digital vs analog type of acquisition. all of these attempts at making something look like it's not just keep falling down in the same ways. but hey, there's a cool tech blog about it this time. film grain filters have been around for a long time, yet people just don't care for them. even in Blu-ray time frame, there was attempts at removing the grain in the encode and applying it in playback. Netflix isn't coming up with anything new, and apparently nothing exciting either based on the results.