Because nothing can exist in America if middlemen don’t make money out of it, the more the better.

You can see a literal example of that thinking in the comments of _heimdall for whom valuable commons are unexploited business cases.

Because stupid people are easy to herd to the polls.

because good data costs money?

how would you feel if you were the SWE on the other side of this API and people demand it for free

This carries the same energy as arguing against "free" healthcare by claiming that doctors shouldn't be expected to work for free.

Nobody is expecting anybody to work for free. We expect government to pay for it. I think you know this and pretend not to for some reason.

There is an SWE on the other side of this API - and I imagine they are enjoying a government salary and pension for operating it... people accessing it for free wouldn't impact them.

Usually the opposite of privatisation is not that something magically appears for free, but that it is funded by a state.

Everything's getting more expensive, and people need to get paid.