Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I agree that the signature for process_handler is weird, but you could steelman it to take a borrowed trait object instead, which would have an extra sigil.

The handler function isn't actually unnecessary, or at least, it isn't superfluous: by default, the signature would include 'a on self as well, and that's probably not what you actually want.

I do think that the example basically boils down to the lifetime syntax though, and yes, while it's a bit odd at first, every other thing that was tried was worse.



> The handler function isn't actually unnecessary, or at least, it isn't superfluous: by default, the signature would include 'a on self as well, and that's probably not what you actually want.

To clarify, I meant the 'a in `Box<dyn Handler + 'a>` in the definition of `process_handler` is unnecessary. I'm not saying that the <'a> parameter in the definition of Handler::handle is unnecessary, which seems to be what you think I said, unless I misunderstood.


Ah yes, I misunderstood you in exactly that way, my apologies.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: