> Google has also removed/threatened to remove prominent firewall VPNs for bullshit reasons (claims that apps violate random policies) ...
I co-develop one such open source "firewall app" for Android, and you're right that apps like ours have been previously removed for blocking ads out-of-the-box. But, removals also happen due to stricter rules/policies that apply to apps using VPN APIs.
Note that, of late, many a popular apps ad-blocking out-of-the-box (like the DuckDuckGo browser with app tracking protection) haven't been removed.
> Unless you own the kernel on every SoC running on your system (including the modem)
I get your point but don't think even a rooted (supervisor) Kernel gets you much guarantee as there always could be a higher privileged hypervisor controlling it.
> Apple's questionable privacy decisions are a lot less worse
They've improved post Celebgate yeah, but the duality is such that... Apple is one of the largest buyers of user data aka "market intelligence" (per folks I know who work in this domain) that (presumably) these other shady apps collect.
These exceptions have been in place since before 2022. Discussion at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32637193
> Google has also removed/threatened to remove prominent firewall VPNs for bullshit reasons (claims that apps violate random policies) ...
I co-develop one such open source "firewall app" for Android, and you're right that apps like ours have been previously removed for blocking ads out-of-the-box. But, removals also happen due to stricter rules/policies that apply to apps using VPN APIs.
Note that, of late, many a popular apps ad-blocking out-of-the-box (like the DuckDuckGo browser with app tracking protection) haven't been removed.
> Unless you own the kernel on every SoC running on your system (including the modem)
I get your point but don't think even a rooted (supervisor) Kernel gets you much guarantee as there always could be a higher privileged hypervisor controlling it.
> Apple's questionable privacy decisions are a lot less worse
They've improved post Celebgate yeah, but the duality is such that... Apple is one of the largest buyers of user data aka "market intelligence" (per folks I know who work in this domain) that (presumably) these other shady apps collect.