Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Ohboy, let's go:

* Calc's pivot tables is clunky, while working on Excel 2010 is like working on butter with a hot knife. No, it's not a "getting used to" thing.

* Basic stuff like filter/sorting tools: Excel has a far better flow that helps you get the job done faster

* DataNitro

* Charting in libreoffice is broken. I use ggplot for most of my day jobs, but sometimes when you need to pull up a quick chart, LibreOffice serves to only nerf your speed. Again, not one of those "getting used to" thing

* Try pivot-tabling a 1M row csv in Calc.

* VBScript (though that's now more and more subplanted by DN)

* Analysis tools - Excel is just so much richer.

These things LibreOffice is better than Excel:

* CSV (excel's a little clunky with CSV import)

* regex search

EDIT: formatting



One more thing Calc is better than Excel: It doesn't screw with your Microsoft Windows 7 windows. Multiwindow in Excel is just broken. Is Excel 2013 any better there?

Anyway, I agree with everything else you said, it matches exactly my experiences with Calc.

That being said I'd prefer Apple to push their iWorks applications over better OOffice - their technological basis is by far the best - the outcome of each click and each edit is completely predictable, the whole rendering engine works consistantly across all three products, so do hotkeys. They're just lacking a lot of sugar on top like the features you mention.


Yes, multi window finally works as it should in Excel 2013. That alone was a reason for me to update the second it was released.


Ahh finally I can have peace of mind. Thanks for that hint.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: