Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

And if I as a "techie" feel threatened an oppressed by those individuals I am.

I am in no way a right winger I was coming at it form the same direction that those who fought in cable street did.

"An injury to one is an injury to all"



That kind of egalitarian viewpoint is alien to these protesters. They are entitled to attack this individual because he is powerful and wrong, and they are powerless and right. You're thinking "no punching" and they're thinking "punch up, not down."


"Threatened" and "oppressed", by non-violent assembly and protest? Come on.


A group posts pictures of your house, your name, and detailed descriptions that attempt to dehumanise you and paint you as some supervillain.

Would I feel threatened and oppressed if I was the target of that? Yes. I'd probably make sure I had weapons in the house.

My lunatic meter went off time and time again while reading their flier. I would not for a second trust that there's not at least one crazy guy that decides to take things one step too far in that group.


They state that they chose to block his personal commute not merely protest at his residence. That means they chose to attempt to prevent him from leaving (since once he left he would be out of their control and may well go to work).

If you were someone that needed to go to work, and needed to drop your child somewhere on the way, and there was a large group of people outside your house with the stated intent of preventing you from doing so, you would not feel threatened? I mean sure they are peaceful while you are inside not attempting to leave, but when you try to oppose their goals by leaving, it raises the question of how dedicated they are to their goal, which I believe would make a rational person feel threatened.

If they had not made the point that the purpose of this was to restrict him from going about life then I would be much more willing to consider the view that he should not feel threatened.


Absolutely its the "perception" by the group of the threat/oppression that is the key thing.

You might want to talk to a few people outside of your group from different ethnicity / group.


So if I hang out in your front lawn and prevent you from leaving your house (in a non-violent manner) with a bunch of my friends, does that make me non-threatening and non-oppressive?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: