Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Why do I have to play the one-armed bandit until I possibly reach one of the 19 MEPs from my home country Austria?


They explained the algorithm in a recent episode of Logbuch Netzpolitik [1]. They weighted all MEPs according to their current stance on the issue, so you're more likely to get the contact info of an opponent of net neutrality than a proponent.

Nonetheless, I also find it slightly frustrating that they didn't include country-matching or at least a language preference setting. After all, the MEP might be more inclined to listen to me if I'm one of their constituents (or if I am at least able to communicate with them).

[1] http://logbuch-netzpolitik.de/lnp094-internet-zero


After all, the MEP might be more inclined to listen to me if I'm one of their constituents (or if I am at least able to communicate with them).

This is something I don't quite understand at EU level.

In the UK, there is a convention that MPs only act for and respond to their own constituents. Randomly e-mailing the MP for somewhere else is extremely unlikely to achieve anything useful at all.

I don't know whether the European Parliament has a similar convention, but even if not, it's hard to see why a random MEP is -- or should be -- swayed in their position by representations from anyone other than the voters to whom they are responsible.

I don't understand why anyone would ever advocate lobbying anyone but their own representatives. Does this actually achieve anything at EU level?


You can easily find all of them over here: http://www.europarl.europa.eu/meps/en/map.html There's an email button on their profile pages.


In the UK we have https://www.writetothem.com/ which allows you to easily contact your own MPS/MEPS. I guess it is a shame it isn't more widely available.


It's a bit frustrating, I clicked 20+ times (or at least it felt like 20+ times) the "get another MEP" button until I could find a French guy (sorry, it might be the EU but I'm not calling a Polish or Greek MEP and hope we can understand each other) and... when a French flag appeared I still had the reflex to click the button again. And it happened a second time, and then I quit.


Try Paul Rübig's office: +33388175749. I have been in touch with his assistant Ms Barbaro there, which is responsible for the net neutrality issue. Here is the letter I sent them regarding the issue (German): https://www.dropbox.com/s/4wmn08zsxwftspw/Brief.pdf


(Paul Rübig is an Austrian MEP)


On the Pi-Phone website - linked in the "call an MEP" widgets - you can choose the country: http://piphone.lqdn.fr/campaign/call2/NetNeutrality-ITRE-nov...


No idea having them on the website is a nice change though.

I always had a problem finding someone to email playing Russian roulette until i find one is slightly easier.


> playing Russian roulette until i find one

Well, you've certainly found the most badass way to get in contact with a politician -- not sure how effective it is over the long term though...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: