Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>Not convinced by this one. Surely reducing the kinetic energy in this scenario is the safest course of action?

How is remaining near an impaired driver vs. leaving them behind the safer option?

It isn't always practical or possible to find another route, and staying behind a drunk driver and thus near them, or running the risk of running into the results of some sort of mistake on their part is certainly more dangerous than putting them safely behind you.

I don't think I've ever been in a situation where a drunk driver has been speeding around at 100mph - they almost universally go near the speed limit, but controlling their vehicle poorly.

I do not want to be in a situation where I am behind them. Even if I let them put a fair amount of distance in front of me, roads are not always well lit. If they crash, or hit something, I might now be having to deal with debris on the road that I won't be able to see easily, or potentially at all until it's too late.

I fail to see a safer course of action outside of just not driving at all, which, as I live in Texas, is distinctly not a possibility.



> and staying behind a drunk driver and thus near them

I don't think anyone is recommending that. I think they're recommending staying behind a drunk driver, and slowing down enough that you're no longer near them and have plenty of time to react to the results of any sort of mistake on their part. I think we can all agree that tailgating a drunk driver is an absolutely terrible idea.

(In general, I try and leave enough space to react to a sober driver's mistakes as well.)

> putting them safely behind you.

"Behind you" means you're in front of them. This is literally putting yourself in the path of danger. If they're relying on cues from traffic, speeding past them may let them know "they need to speed up" - and now they have some nice tail lights that are much easier to follow than those road stripes...

> I might now be having to deal with debris on the road that I won't be able to see easily, or potentially at all until it's too late.

You might have to deal with that whether or not a drunk driver wrecked in front of you. And even if you've left one behind you, what are the chances there's not one in front of you too?

You'll have more time to react going slower. If you keep your windows clean, your prescription up to date, your headlights in working order, and put down your phone - and I'd wager most debris you can't see in time to avoid is going to be much smaller, and as a result much less dangerous, than an entire car threatening to collide with you going the speed limit.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: