Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> The entire economic system is built around people trying to get the best deal possible for themselves ...

Getting the best deal possible is one factor, but it's not the only one, it's not dogma, and it doesn't justify bad behavior.

I think your post is a simplified approach to a complex world. For example, it assumes that the marketplace is free and fair, which it clearly is not. The powerful often use their power to prevent competition, or even to write the rules (via influence in government) of the 'free' competition. Also, profiting from others' suffering is wrong.

Finally, our economic system, while good relative to most in human history, could be greatly improved. Let's not allow a dogmatic idea that it is ideal stop us from getting better. For one thing, it could be made more free and more fair.

> it's not Uber or anyone else's job or responsibility to guarantee anyone or anybody a certain standard of living.

I strongly disagree. We all have responsibilities to our communities and society; if people didn't meet those responsibilities, the communities and society would fall apart. Those who don't do their part are parasites on those who do, in my humble opinion.



Great, so you're concerned about some people being more competitive than others in the free market. So what's your response? A monopolistic ostenisbly communally-controlled central power to oversee and address alleged abuses? Excellent, you just created a superbly manipulable tool of power for society's most capable individuals to wield. You just made problems of fundamental unfairness much worse, not better.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: