Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> those "downed" missiles somehow cause a "minor" damage to the Patriot battery doing it

Thirty missiles were fired, twenty nine intercepted [1]. Sustaining minor, i.e. quickly repaired, damage after a 97% interception rate against a supposedly technologically advanced adversary is pretty damn good.

[1] https://www.reuters.com/world/falling-debris-causes-fires-tw....



For some reason, you forget the usual disclaimer "Ukraine says" and instead state it as a fact. It's hard to take them at face value similarly to their Russian counterparts. Also the "minor" claim is also maid by an interested party. If it was just a paint job, I think they would've preferred to simply stay silent on the matter. With available objective data we know that two explosions have happened on the ground level and that 2 launched Patriot missiles have failed, which is a fairly high value.


> you forget the usual disclaimer "Ukraine says" and instead state it as a fact

It’s been corroborated by the U.S. and allies [1]. The Kremlin hasn’t disputed the charge.

(The U.S. also said a PATRIOT battery was damaged while Kyiv claimed no such thing. As others have speculated, this was probably a radar unit that was targeted and damaged.)

[1] https://www.businessinsider.com/patriot-kill-shot-impressive...


> we know that two explosions have happened on the ground level

Site a source for that please.

Do you think that when you "down" a hypersonic missile the debris fall harmlessly to the ground or do they continue moving?


[flagged]


At this distance I can't even tell that they're explosions, let alone Patriot batteries (there weren't only Patriot systems here). I'm sorry but that is not objective proof of anything.


>At this distance I can't even tell that they're explosions

Sure, it could've been swamp gas from a weather balloon trapped in a thermal pocket, which has reflected the light from Venus.


Or perhaps the corroberated evidence is valid and you're simply wasting people's time with unqualified and unbased doubts.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: